|
Beginner |
Intermediate |
Policy-Maker |
| Individual
Effort |
Mastered cut and paste technology;
didn't do much with available information. |
Definitely learned from the
activity. Shows increased awareness of different points of view,
and is able to provide examples to support opinions. |
Clearly understands the subtleties
of the subject. Is able to discuss different points of view and integrate
information from outside sources. |
| Teamwork |
Everyone had a say, but it's
not apparent that much listening -- or learning -- took place. It's
not clear that the team grasps other points of view except as a "right
vs. wrong" issue. |
These people listened to one
another and managed to blend a variety of viewpoints into a coherent position.
Still room for deeper understanding and synthesis. |
This team managed to bring
clarity to a very complex issue, and were able to communicate with other
teams in a way that clarified things for everyone. They also listened
well -- to one another and to the other teams. |
| Final
Product |
Lacks clarity and cohesiveness.
Draft quality rather than final product. |
A good solid effort.
A little bit of glue showing here and there, but mostly this is a coherent
recommendation. |
This recommendation is
thought-provoking, and creative, synthesizing many complex
ideas and competing points of view. Obviously a great deal of energy,
effort, and skill was brought to the assignment. |